Top sellers

• 
  Available

  Cheesecake - Plain

  Philly Cream Cheese is the base for this masterpiece. This is NOT New York style, this is the creamy, melt in your mouth kind. 1 Day Shipping ONLY - Cake shipped up to two (2) business days after ordering.

  $40.95 Add to cart
  View
• 
  Available

  Buche de Noel - Hand Deliver ONLY

  Buche de Noels are available for pick up or delivery in the New York City Area. Choices are: Vanilla Chiffon with Chocolate Mousse or Caramel Cream filling, Chocolate Chiffon with White Chocolate Mousse or Caramel Cream filling. All...

  $40.00 Add to cart
  View
• 
  Available

  Mini Chocolate Chocolate Chip...

  Pretty much the name says it all. These are a little crunchier than their blonde based counterparts. 30 cookies.

  $25.95 Add to cart
  View
• 
  Available

  Mini Peanut Butter

  Maple syrup is the secret to our peanut butter cookies. 30 cookies.

  $25.95 Add to cart
  View
• 
  Custom Cakes

  24-Hour Notice REQUIRED. Send an email to hopefaithandgluttony@msn.com to receive our price list for cakes, or call 718-706-6616 to discuss your choices over the phone.

  
  View
• 
  Available

  Pumpkin Pie with Ginger Cookie...

  $25.95 Add to cart
  View
• 
  Available

  Apple Pie with Pie Crust Top

  $25.95 Add to cart
  View
• 
  Available

  Truly Gluttonous DELUXE

  Want to make a splash? Feed a crowd? The Deluxe is for you! 75 cookies and a bakers dozen of Bars - 14 of each cookie: Chocolate Chip, Oatmeal Raisin, Chocolate Chocolate Chip, Peanut Butter and Sugar. 2 Fudgey Brownies, 2 O-Bars, 2...

  $89.95 Add to cart
  View
• 
  Available

  Mini Easter Assortment

  16 Mini Easter Sugar Cookies

  $30.00 Add to cart
  View
• 
  Available

  Butterfinger Bites Box

  12 pieces of our NEW Butterfinger Bites! Peanut Butter confectionary filling with crushed Butterfingers mixed in, covered in dark chocolate.

  $25.00 Add to cart
  View
• 
  Available

  Funfetti Sugar Cookies

  Our classic Sugar Cookie recipe with the sprinkles on the inside vs. the outside. We do them in seasonal colors - Fall, Christmas/Hannuka, Valentines, St. Patty's Day, Easter/Spring, and USA/4th of July. 30 cookies per order

  $25.95 Add to cart
  View
• 
  Available

  Flourless Chocolate Cake

  This fudge-like creation will make you wonder why you ever need to cook with flour! It is rich and flavorful and covered in Ganache. 1 Day Shipping ONLY - Cake shipped up to two (2) business days after ordering.

  $26.95 Add to cart
  View
• 
  Available

  Cheesecake - Pumpkin

  A nice diversion from the norm - Cream Cheese and Pumpkin are the base for this ginger cookie crust creation. 1 Day Shipping ONLY - Cake shipped up to two (2) business days after ordering.

  $40.95 Add to cart
  View
• 
  Available

  Caramels - Plain & Chocolate...

  TIN INCLUDED! Caramels made from scratch, sent as a lucious ball in a wrapper or enrobed in dark chocolate.  18 piece per order- 9 plain, 9 chocolate covered

  $25.95 Add to cart
  View
• 
  Available

  Lovely Edible Images

  TIN INCLUDED! 6 sugar cookies with newly designed Valentine's Day hearts! Bordered with sanding sugar to give it an extra sweet crunch.

  $20.00 Add to cart
  View
• 
  Available

  Dreidels, Stars of David & Happy...

  12 cookies. Dreidels, Stars of David and Menorahs -  Just add the Gelt and you are set for 8 nights of candle lighting!

  $36.00 Add to cart
  View
• 
  Available

  Brownie Box

  For the Brownie Lover in all of us - 2 of each kind of brownie: Fudgey Brownie, Butterscotch Blondie Brownie, Mint Brownie, Cheesecake Brownie, Peanut Butter Brownie and Raspberry Brownie.

  $39.95 Add to cart
  View
• 
  Available

  Sugar Daddy Bark

  Our new Sugar Daddy bark has pops of chewy caramel balls with whole pecans mixed with dark chocolate, sprinkled with sea salt on top. Order by the half pound - 1 lb minimum.

  $7.50
  View
• 
  Available

  Mississippi Mudd Pie

  $30.95 Add to cart
  View
• 
  Available

  Assorted Easter Eggs

  A combination of our mini and medium easter sugar cookie eggs.  

  $25.00 Add to cart
  View